91-
92
JAMES SUCKLING: "Good structure and focus here with medium body and firm tannins. Juicy berry fruit in the center-palate. Lightly chewy at the end."
17
WEINWISSER: "Feingliedriges rotbeeriges Bouquet, Majoran, heller Tabak und Johannisbeergelee. Am geradlinigen Gaumen mit weicher Textur, stützender Rasse sowie engmaschigem Körper, dicht. Im gebündelten, sehr straffen Finale mit Schattenmorelle, Graphit und feinkörnigem Extrakt."
91
DECANTER: "With pleasing ripe cassis and plum, this wine in the northern Médoc shines albeit not as bright as some of the top Haut-Médocs, as I notice somewhat austere tannins, lacking some charm, but I like its mid-palate concentration and the iodine freshness on the finish that bodes well. Ageing in 33% new oak should smoothen some of the edges."
90-
92
JEB DUNNUCK: "I continue to love this Haut-Médoc, and the 2023 Château Charmail is a lovely, round, supple, medium-bodied effort that has tons of charm in its red fruits, spice, savory, leather, and herbal aromas and flavors. It's balanced, has soft tannins, and will put a smile on your face right out of the gate."
90-
92
THE WINE CELLAR INSIDER: "Floral, with cedar, tobacco, camphor, and bright, red fruits from start to finish, the wine is creamy on the palate, with a fresh, fruity finish. This is one of those super value wines from the Haut Medoc that savvy wine buyers should be all over. Drink from 2026-2036."
90
VINUM: "Feinduftig, blumig, rote Beerenfrucht; schlanker Gaumen, straff, mit Frische, wohl dosierte Tannine, gute Länge. Ein lebhafter Charmail."