92-93 JAMES SUCKLING: "The polish and integration to this is impressive with purity of fruit and brightness, too. Medium body. Fruity and very clean and focused. Will be beautiful in bottle."
90-92 JEB DUNNUCK: "Notes of smoked earth, plums, blackberries, and spicy wood all emerge from the 2018 Château Pierre 1Er. Medium to full-bodied, nicely balanced, with both texture and elegance on the palate, drink this pure, beautiful Saint-Émilion over the coming 10-15 years."